I think you're looking at this career in the wrong way. Privateers are extremely powerful, especially in PvP. It isn't their ship selection that matters -- it's what they do with any ship they captain. Compared to Navy, Privateers have the skills and Navy has the ships.
Regarding career comparisons:
Pirates: They pretty much share the same ship list as privateers. The other ones they can capture are flagged for PvP, which is a major negative. The pirate-specific refits are not actually very popular in actual play except for the Cursed Blade, so there is no evidence that the pirate-specific refits are incredibly awesome. Pirates do not have a ship advantage over privateers.
Freetraders: The FT-only ships are also not produced or used very often and are definitely not powerful and desirable in this regard in terms of combat. Privateers have it all over Freetraders in terms of combat ships. The SOL-like ship you mention that is just for FT'ers is the Couronne writ ship, and that means its comparable example is the Mastercraft Pommern writ ship. The MC Pommern can pretty much obliterate a Couronne. Freetraders do not have a ship advantage over privateers in terms of combat, which is what Privateers are all about.
Navy: Most navy players will never, ever sail anything bigger than a 4th rate. Those that do use 1st-3rd rate ships will use them so rarely that they are not really valid for comparison. The rest of the high-end Navy ships are indeed very powerful, but this is where we trade ships for skills in terms of balance. Privateer skills give them a lot of advantages that Navy skills don't.
Quote:
|
the Mignone Privateer Indiaman is a stat variation of a freetrader ship
|
The Mignone has 14 more guns than the base ship, which nearly doubles its mid and long range DPS. It's got 32 12lb guns with a reload bonus, which means it will outgun most ships at the right range. I wouldn't dismiss that as just a stat variation.
Quote:
|
We see a whisper of this in the Mignone privateer indiaman, but that is a level 50 ship outgunned by many ships of the same or lesser level, including several pure merchants, lower level pirate merchant conversions, lower level 4th rates, and even some frigates.
|
The only pirate merchant conversion with more guns is a level 50 refit ship that you have to buy with PvP Marks of Victory, so it's not lower level. There are also no lower level 4th rates -- all 4th rates are level 50. The Mignone is very powerful and compares well to the other ships in its range, especially when used with the Privateer's skill selection.
We don't believe there are any serious issues with privateer ship selection.