Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Undrsiege
|
I just checked and as far as we can see through our admin tools, this design is already approved. Again, if you don't see it in-game, please follow up with a
support request.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Xaphod
So.. out of all the flags and sails I've submitted I've so far had two rejected .. I've posted into the appeals thread because frankly I've no idea why and figure I at least deserve an explanation.
I expect it's caused by people speed voting to get credits :|
|
I just double checked and I don't see any of your work having been sent back for want of positive votes. That said, it sounds like some people are not receiving the feedback provided by Admin; Kevin T. is looking into that issue.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Dek Anon
J1. the " Hot Votes".. Supposedly there is a magical number that you have to reach in votes to pass your sail or flag to the approval stage.. What is the number? Its never mentioned.
Suggestion: How about some sort of a vote counter with each entry showing you how many positive votes you have and how many you have to go. Or , if you want to keep the magical mystery " hot Vote" number a continuing secret, how about some sort of leveling bar or something just so we can see that there IS progress in the voting.
2. If one has a sail that has been approved, and wanted to "tweek" it slightly while keeping the overall theme and texture the same ( i.e. reverse profile of an icon on a sail or enlarge the symbol) they have to reapply for voting once again. I PERSONALLY have seen sails that have been approved reinstated in the voting process with the SAME theme and coloration and texture, but a repositioning of an icon from the left side to the right.IMO this is taking up the time and space of the 2.0
Suggestion: produce a way that a sail that is approved be able to " tweek" and reinstate for IMMEDIATE approval" bypassing the whole voting process again. Possibly attaching the approved sail or flag alongside of the tweeked version.. I think this will clean up the process even better and faster.
|
1. The "magic number" isn't set in stone: it's tuned based on how the system is behaving overall. So a "number of votes until this content is moved into Pending Approval" isn't going to be a consistently helpful way to track your design's "progress" through the system. Plus, even though the system is hard to game or bot or otherwise cheat, providing that info gives those who would a tool to use against the system.
Besides, content should be in and out of the system
within one week at the longest. In the majority of cases it's going to be in voting even less. That's a very small timeframe in which it could be a benefit, while being long enough to cause problems.
2. The forum is the best place to work on a design and "tweak" it. Submit your content for "Review" rather than going straight to "In Voting" -- you can change it and perfect your design, and if you open a forum thread using the [ u c ]####[ / u c ] tag, your changes will be automatically visible on the forum for other community members to react to.